A NeuroDevelopmental Approach: Right Intervention, Right Time {EP 47}
If you’re reading this blog or listening to this podcast, my guess is that this isn’t your first experience with a parenting ‘expert.’
If you read this blog because you’re a therapist, this probably isn’t your first experience learning from a child therapist ‘expert.’
The parents and professionals who come to me, my blog, and my podcast are searching for something new.
Listen on the podcast or keep reading!
Something that Makes Sense & Something That Works.
You may have had a felt sense all along that some of the most mainstream ways we support kids and behaviors just didn’t make sense to you.
Or maybe they did make sense but then they just simply didn’t work.
And one thing led to another and now you’re here, with me! On my blog, or listening to my podcast.
Like You…
Like many of you, I also was searching for something that made more sense and that honestly just worked better. I’ve always had the drive to look for relational approaches–to truly understand what is going on underneath behavior–and have been studying attachment since high school.
Also like many of you, I had plenty of experiences of being trained in more behavioral or even just more mainstream approaches to children and behavior.
They Didn’t Work!
My therapy room was destroyed.
I was hurt. Several times.
Something wasn’t right and I knew it right away.
I suppose it was possible that I just wasn’t a very good therapist– and I probably wasn’t– back in those early days. But still. Something wasn’t right.
What I was equipped with– cognitive approaches, child centered play therapy, behavioral interventions and consequences– was clearly not working for the children I was working with.
Or their parents.
They were parents like you- good parents who tried. If those approaches were going to work, these families wouldn’t have landed in my office.
So I did what I do which is I got a bit obsessive about figuring it out.
The Trampoline that Changed Everything
I got lucky and had an officemate and mentor who kept a trampoline in his office. And who didn’t have a lot of time to coddle my ego and just straight up let me know I was doing it wrong.
I didn’t know what to do different but jumping on a trampoline seemed more fun than getting bit– so I was intrigued.
This led me to Bruce Perry- where I learned the science to justify the trampoline in my office (and ultimately a yoga ball, pogo stick, balance board, and an aerial hammock and swing).
Then I discovered the boarder field of the relational neurosciences- starting with Interpersonal Neurobiology, Polyvagal theory, Memory Reconsolidation Theory, and Affect Regulation Theory.
This literally changed everything for me.
Interpersonal Neurobiology
Interpersonal Neurobiology isn’t techniques or tools. It’s not even a clinical theory. It’s a theory of being human.
It has changed my core fundamental understanding of what it means to be human and therefore has given me a map that I can bring into the office and apply to treatment planning.
More than that– it’s given me a map that I can bring into every aspect of my life.
Behavior is Simply a Clue
Behavior is simply a clue about a person’s autonomic state- felt safety, regulation, and their openness- or seeking- of connection.
The tools, techniques, and clinical theory I was equipped with made assumptions about my client’s state of regulation and brain development based solely on chronological age.
Child-centered play therapy makes the assumption that a five-year-old has the regulation and internalized sense of self that was needed to benefit from symbolic or projective play.
A NeuroDevelopmental Approach
Learning about Interpersonal Neurobiology, and especially Dr. Bruce Perry’s Neurosequential Model of Therapeutics, validated for me was that chronological age is largely irrelevant in the therapy room and that I needed to meet my clients- the kids and the adults- in the correct neurodevelopmental space.
For kids and adults with histories of complex and relational trauma, and for many of my kids with really dysregulated behaviors, I wasn’t meeting them where they were.
I wanted them to have symbolic and metaphor play skills that they simply didn’t have.
Yet.
You may have heard Dr. Perry’s catchy phrase that the order of operations is always regulate, relate, reason.
Regulate first.
When I was a new therapist, I didn’t even know what regulate meant.
I had no idea how the autonomic nervous system was related to therapy.
Turns out…a lot. Like…everything.
Autonomic Nervous System
The autonomic nervous system is underneath everything. Certainly behavior.
We want to believe we have a lot of cognitive control over our behavior but really, we don’t. We can work to develop more conscious awareness and control over our behavior, but even still– most behavior is implicit.
People who experienced trauma, loss, toxic stress while their autonomic nervous system was busy developing have had the regulation of their autonomic nervous system impacted.
Ultimately this means that their behavior is pretty baffling, confusing, and overwhelming.
Right Intervention Wrong Time
Child Center Play Therapy or other approaches that support the client in engaging in projective, metaphor or symbolic play is not a bad treatment approach. It’s an excellent treatment approach and provides the safety and the distance for the child to touch distressing memories in a safe space so they can integrate.
Cognitive therapies or approaches that help kids identify thinking errors and coping skills are not a bad treatment approach. Becoming mindful of our own thoughts and making the previously held implicit beliefs more explicit can be an important step in increasing integration.
These aren’t bad or wrong therapies. They just are often used at the wrong time, especially with children with histories of complex trauma.
Complex trauma in early life impacts the develop of the autonomic nervous system, regulation, and sense of self. It impacts the develop of the neurobiology that is needed to benefit from child-centered play therapy.
Beyond Trauma Informed
Complex trauma has always been my area of expertise but studying the Relational Neurosciences has shifted my understanding of ALL humans.
Regulation, felt-safety, and connection- our autonomic state- is underneath all of our behaviors.
We had to start with regulate.
If we have children or clients who have autonomic nervous system vulnerabilities due to trauma or toxic stress, we may have to start with with therapies and interventions that support the lowest part of the brain. The child may need us to stay with those types of interventions for a while.
This might feel frustrating is your child is seven or 10 or 15- and you want them to have age-appropriate capabilities for impulse control, cause and effect, and self-awareness. You want them to have an age-appropriate ‘pause’ before they act so they can make a choice. They may even demonstrate those skills occasionally.
But children with a history of complex trauma who have a shaky foundation of the brain quickly lose their ability to have relational or logical behaviors when their autonomic nervous system is stressed.
Their foundation collapses.
Dr. Perry’s work and the Neurosequential Model of Therapeutics shows us that children with a shaky foundation in the brain (brainstem and autonomic nervous system disorganization and dysregulation) need therapeutic experiences that are based in the here and now (not prompting self-reflection or symbolic play) to promote organization and regulation.
This neurodevelopmental lens also helps us make sense of behaviors as a completely appropriate response given the vulnerabilities in their nervous system, as opposed to a behavior problem that needs punished or a characterological problem.
The problem isn’t the child’s behavior. The problem is the disruption of the energy and arousal that is fueling that behavior.
Strengthen the Foundation
If I don’t want to get hurt in a therapy session, helping the child developing coping skills to calm down before they start hitting and throwing things will only be helpful if the problem is that they don’t have coping skills. But this is almost never the case. The problem is that they aren’t regulated
Coping skills are important. But if the child’s energy and arousal is dysregulated to the point that they are rapidly escalating, continually making “mountains out of molehills” or behaving in head-scratching ways that leave adults feeling baffled and overwhelmed, what that child needs isn’t coping skills. They need increased regulation in their autonomic nervous system, which is in the bottom-most and inside-most part of their brain.
Teaching coping skills to a dysregulated child is like focusing on the decorations when you are earthquake-proofing your house. It’s way more important to strengthen the foundation, not nail picture frames to the wall. If the house collapses, it doesn’t really matter if the picture frames didn’t fall down.
So…how do we do this?
Well, I’m glad you asked!
This is what I’m going to focusing on for the next six weeks on my blog and podcast– strengthening the foundation of the brain. I have some great guests lined up, too, starting with a guest interview next week about the Safe and Sound Protocol.
At the end of this series, you’ll have the opportunity to go deeper and get more practical, more hands on with the material, and of course, waaaay more support by joining us in The Club– because strengthening the foundation of the brain will be our focus in The Club October through the end of the year.
If you’re a professional and you’re curious to learn how I’ve incorporated this bottom-up approach inside a traditional hour-a-week outpatient therapy paradigm, I have something special in store for you this fall, too. Stay tuned 😊
Therapeutic Moments
I’ve come to be a believer in therapeutic moments. So much healing and changing can happen– it must happen– outside the therapeutic hour.
I want to empower you to become your child’s expert, to see behavior for what it truly is, and give you the tools to help regulate and organize your child’s nervous system- because that’s when the behavior you are looking for will begin to emerge.
What Behavior Really Is…
If you’d like to get a jump-start on this new paradigm while you impatiently wait for next week’s blog and podcast on building the foundation of the brain, watch my F R E E video-series on What Behavior Really Is…and How to Change It.
Just let me know where to send the links!
Robyn
- Scaffolding Relational Skills as Brain Skills with Eileen Devine {EP 199} - November 12, 2024
- All Behavior Makes Sense {EP 198} - October 8, 2024
- How Can the Club Help Me? {EP 197} - October 4, 2024
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!